Insurance agencies · Ohio

Insurance agencies in Westerville, OH

114 insurance agents in Westerville with phone numbers, 34 with email addresses. Search the list, unlock the ones you want and start calling today.

Get the Westerville list freeSee a sample
114
businesses
100%
have a phone number
30%
have an email address (34)
—
average Google rating
Sample

A sample of insurance agencies in Westerville

Twelve of the 114 insurance agents on the list. Phone numbers and emails unlock in the app — 1 credit per business, both together.

BusinessCategoryRatingWebsitePhoneEmail
Chris Callen Insurance Agent - Matthew Mitchell AgtInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Washington EnterprisesInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Belpedio Thomas InsuranceInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Benchmark InsuranceInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Willer Paul Insurance AgencyInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Rise Insurance OhioInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
ESP Benefit DesignInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Kalmbaugh Insurance AgencyInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Billy Tecklenburg - State Farm Insurance AgentInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Thomas Smith at Comparion Insurance AgencyInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
April Schaad - State Farm Insurance AgentInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available
Jennings Meredith TullisInsurance Agency—Yes(614) •••-••••Available

Showing 12 of 114. Data refreshed October 2026.

The market

What Westerville's insurance agents look like

0% of rated insurance agents here hold 4.5★ or better — there is room for businesses that push for reviews.
0 carry a perfect 5.0★ rating; 114 have no rating yet — prime prospects for review and reputation services.
17 (15%) have no website listed — a ready-made list for web design and SEO offers.
25% link a Facebook or Instagram page from their listing.

Most common listings

  • Insurance Agency103
  • Insurance Agency; Financial Service; Legal Service6
  • Insurance Agency; Office3
  • Human Resources Agency; Insurance Agency; Hospital1
  • Insurance Agency; Office; Structure1

Area codes

  • (614)110
  • (502)1
  • (740)1
  • (800)1
  • (888)1
Playbook

How to sell to insurance agents in Westerville

Independent and captive insurance agencies sell personal and commercial lines. They buy leads, tools and services that grow their book and cut service time.

Who sells to insurance agents

  • Lead vendors and marketing agencies
  • Agency-management and quoting software
  • Call handling and virtual assistants
  • Websites and SEO
  • Carrier appointments and networks

What keeps owners up at night

  • Steady flow of quote requests
  • Renewals and retention
  • Admin time per policy
  • Competing with direct-to-consumer carriers
When to reach themMid-morning, Tuesday to Thursday.
The angle that worksBook of business growth. Ask how many new households they wrote last month.
Reaching out in the USB2B cold email is governed by CAN-SPAM: honest headers and subject lines, a physical address and an opt-out you honor. Phone outreach has its own rules, especially for cell phones. Read our CAN-SPAM guide and cold-calling rules before you start.
FAQ

Questions about Westerville insurance agents leads

How many insurance agencies in Westerville, OH are in the database?
114 insurance agencies in Westerville, OH, as of October 2026. 114 of them have a phone number and 34 have an email address.
How much does it cost to get these leads?
Every account starts with 25 free credits. Unlocking a contact (phone and email together) costs 1 credit. The Starter plan is $39/month for 2,500 credits — about 1.6¢ a contact — so the whole Westerville list of 114 costs less than one month of Starter. See pricing.
Can I export the list to a dialer or CRM?
Yes. Unlocked contacts export to CSV, Excel or JSON with phone, email, website, address, category and rating, ready for any dialer or CRM.
Where does the data come from?
From public business listings — the same information insurance agents publish so customers can find them — cleaned, de-duplicated by phone number and refreshed regularly. Businesses can ask to be removed at any time.

Insurance agencies in other cities

Columbus, OHCincinnati, OHCleveland, OHDayton, OHAll insurance agencies →

Other businesses in Westerville

Construction companiesMedical clinicsRestaurantsSalons and spasReal estate officesFinancial advisors and lendersEverything in Westerville →

Start calling Westerville insurance agents today

25 free credits, no card. Search "insurance agencies in Westerville" and unlock your first 25 contacts.

Get these leads freeSee pricing